Indicia Desk.
Log in
Radar
Data
Whales ยท Futures Map Whales ยท Options Trades Whales vs Crowd Whale Fragility Altseason Max Pain Gamma ยท GEX Fear & Greed Volatility
Research
Investigations ยท whale stories Case: โ‰ˆ$1.39M in a range DVOL ยท 907 days of fear Max pain ยท track record Whale case audit
Strategies
Journal ยท 92 strategies 3 strategies ยท access Builder Strategy profiles Alerts
Services
Morning letter Test an idea (Check) Signal channel audit Whale Watch alerts Pricing
Method
How it works Glossary Podcast About Log in ๐Ÿ†˜ Contact us Log in

Research ยท data from 10 Mar to 4 Sep 2026

Do market makers steer price toward their theta?

Option sellers earn time decay, called theta. A popular belief says market makers, who mostly sell options, push price toward the strikes where they collect the most of it. We tested that on BTC and ETH options on Deribit.

Short answer: no. Over 178 days, price moved toward the strike with the most theta about as often as away from it, between 48% and 56% of the time on every horizon from one hour to seven days. Shuffled price moves give the same. The levels themselves moved after price, not before it.

How we tested

What we found

HorizonWindowsBTC: moved toward the peakETH: moved toward the peak
1 h419949.8% ยท p 0.8749.8% ยท p 0.65
4 h105551.8% ยท p 0.2451.1% ยท p 0.51
12 h35155.3% ยท p 0.0648.1% ยท p 0.47
24 h17655.1% ยท p 0.2647.2% ยท p 0.55
3 d5761.4% ยท p 0.1643.9% ยท p 0.48
7 d2552.0% ยท p 1.0052.0% ยท p 1.00

p is the chance of a share this far from 50% if price did not care about the peak; none comes below 0.05. From 1 to 24 hours the test would have caught a real pull of 53% to 57%. At 3 and 7 days there are too few windows to tell either way.

Theta is largest where option sellers are shortest gamma. On these dates that was near the put and call walls, about 6% to 8% below price and 4% to 7% above it. Hedging short gamma pushes price away from such strikes, so a pull toward them would have been odd to begin with.

The levels followed price. A day's change in max pain, the gamma flip and the gamma peak tracked the previous day's change in price (t from 2.3 to 4.6). The other way round we found nothing.

Max pain sat close to the average price of the past three days: a median distance of 0.56% for BTC and 0.81% for ETH. That is why it often looks right in hindsight.

One small effect held up. When price sat near the gamma flip, the next four hours were a little calmer: realized volatility about 0.78 to 0.87 of implied, against 0.87 to 0.92 elsewhere. Price sitting near its own three-day average explains half to two thirds of that, and it says nothing about direction.

Limits

FAQ

Is the theta peak the same as max pain?

No. In this sample the theta peak for expiries within a week sat a median 4.2% (BTC) and 3.5% (ETH) away from max pain. Max pain stays near price; the theta peak jumps between the walls.

Are option levels useless then?

They show where positions are parked today, which is worth knowing. We read them as a map of positioning, not as a direction. How often max pain and the walls held at expiry is in our expiry record.

Is this investment advice?

No. It is a research result on past data. Nothing here tells you to buy or sell.

Read one morning first

The letter explains why BTC moved over the past day, where Hyperliquid whales and the crowd stand, and which Deribit prices carry the most open interest. The first 7 letters are free.

Get 7 free letters
Not investment advice. Research on past data. Past results do not predict future ones.

Related: Expiry record ยท GammaFlip vs INDICIA ยท Crypto options tools

๐ŸŒ ะฃะšะ  ยท EN ยท ES ยท PT ยท ะ ะฃะก
Privacy